Here’s the thing. Jack Kennedy got it the way he wanted it. All at once. That’s the way to go. My grandfather, Joe Villari was really never sick a day in his life, and then dropped dead. It damn near killed the family, but it was a blessing for him. He deserved no less.
Well, JFK literally got his brains blown out in Dealey Plaza in Dallas on November 22, 1963. Apparently, I’ve read, as his Presidential limo sped off in search of a miracle, Rufus Youngblood, the Secret Service Agent who shielded Lyndon Johnson, looked at Paul Landis, another agent, and gestured thumbs down. Youngblood was a combat veteran of WWII, Army Air Corps. He had presumably seen more than his share of young men with their heads blown off. He knew a confirmed kill when he saw it. For the rest of us, it took sixty years.
Now don’t worry. I’m not gonna inflict the Zapruder film, or even worse, the photo of the back seat of Kennedy’s limousine, a photo of which I recently saw for the first time. Brains and all. Worse than I thought; so if you’re so inclined, go find it yourself. I was never in combat, so my capacity to be shocked by what a high-powered weapon can do to the human body is still there. Yeah. Still. This is really more about the slow death of a set of assumption, most naive, about politics, America, and the world. I’ll keep the gore to a minimum.
There is this “Do you Remember where you were and what you were doing when you found out?” Well, sure. I was in school, seventh grade; I think it was late morning on a Friday, a sunny Fall day in Philly. I remember a sort of flurry of activity by the classroom door late morning or early afternoon. I guess the Principal, Sister Marie Suzanne, was going around telling all the teachers. She did not, as was her wont, get on the PA and announce that Kennedy had been shot. Even she knew better than to do that. My teacher, Sister Marie Bellarmine, I think, walked to the front of the class, gestured for silence, and said something like “Boys and Girls, I need you to sit still and to pray. President Kennedy was shot in Dallas.”
Now, this was, as you can imagine, a BFD. On so many levels it is hard to think or remember how I– or most of us– processed it. We had lived through the Missile Crisis a year before. Even at that age (11), we thought the odds were pretty good were were all gonna die. Unpleasantly. Watching a big flash and a mushroom cloud before whatever the Hell was gonna happen happened. Maybe from under our school desks. I really wanted to die at home looking out my back window. I remember how relieved everyone was when the Russians backed down. If anything, Kennedy rose in a lot of our opinions. Not that we didn’t adore him anyway. There were, of course, a few asshole kids who found the news funny. It was Penn Wynne.
Ok. Nobody with an ounce of sense has any illusions about St Jack. I remember seeing a stained glass window in some Catholic parish where they had canonized him after he was killed. I can’t find it–and I suspect it’s gone. Maybe the week Dame Judith Exner confirmed that she, JFK, Sam Giancana and Johnny Roselli were, well, identified as an item (not simultaneously, please), the parish called in a glazier and sent JFK packing. I don’t know. I don’t really care. This was not part of the Church’s Magisterium in 1963. Richard Cardinal Cushing never threatened Kennedy with withholding the sacraments, although I’m pretty sure he must have known all about the Kennedy men, starting with father Joe. Kennedy pere’s career in Hollywood with Gloria Swanson and Marlene Dietrich. If you haven’t seen the film True Confessions with De Niro and Duvall, I’d recommend it. Sort of clue you into the way things got done back then in the Catholic Church. While the wife’s away, the Old Man gets to play, especially if he’s paying the priest–or the Diocese (A synopsis is below for you to copy)
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/true-confessions-1981And his infidelities were, maybe, the least of it. JFK was a very sick man, in terrible physical condition. He probably should not have been President for medical reasons. He suffered from Addison’s Disease, had undergone multiple back surgeries (some related to the treatment of Addison’s, and some to his combat injury in the Pacific when his PT boat got rammed out from under him. We didn’t know any of this. Jack Kennedy was portrayed as young, vigorous, virile, and an aficionado of some rugby-style touch football with the rest of the Kennedy Clan. He did the nautical thing with the rest of the toffs up in Newport in those damn sunglasses (the signature model is still for sale). He was glamorous, man, just like his spouse, Jacqueline Bouvier, who was too gloriously feminine for any idiot to call “hot” (not a word in those days, other than for “tramp”). Put those two up again any dowdy Republican couple (Dwight and Mamie, for God’s sake–or, gross, Nixon and Pat), and game, set and match. No wonder the Press called Kennedy’s White House “Camelot”. Hell, Jackie spoke good French and, I think, decent Spanish. He sprinkled Latin into his speeches. “Civis Romanus Sum”: Donald Trump barely speaks English. You want a sample of JFK in action? OK. Here are a few.
I don’t want to try anyone’s patience, so I’ll stop.
See, this was my JFK–our JFK, yeah, the Catholic JFK. And that latter bears emphasis, because in 1960, this was still a big deal. Not just because he’d be the first (Al Smith, you may recall, ran and lost in 1928, and he was Catholic). But because, until 1958, Pius XII had been Pope. This is strictly RC cognoscenti stuff, but Pius’ whole project was to put the world–yeah, as the whole thing, Orbis Terrarum–under Canon Law. Canon Law is, in essence, the legal code that governs the Catholic Church. You don’t need to know much other than it’s not clear whether Pius was part of the Church that as of yet recognized the independent existence of Church and State. His predecessors, like Pius X and XI, sure as Hell didn’t. So whether or not Kennedy was gonna subscribe to this doctrine (as ridiculous as it may seem today) was a live issue. And then there had been the Radio Priest in the 1930s, Father Coughlin, a virulent anti-semite, denouncing FDR and the New Deal of which JFK’s old man was a part. They had to silence Coughlin, but he was really bad news. How bad? Here
So, believe me, this was the face of the Catholic Church to many people. The heyday of the Universal Church. And it was not pretty. So wonder not that JFK was putting distance between him and the Whore of Rome rather than with the whores he slept with.
So, as it were, this is where I came in–not just me, but lots of us. We were naive. We were innocent of much Catholicism other than the Baltimore Catechism (which my buddy Jim Maule can still quote beyond “Who is God?”), we were probably getting most of our politics from our families; we saw the quarters on which some wits had red nail-polished birettas on George Washington (I had one for years, to remind myself, even at Princeton) to insinuate a Popish takeover in the making. And then came (not in strict chronological order, I know), Jack Kennedy and the Houston speech. Boy, that did it for me. Now I’ll give some context after, but I urge you to at least pay some attention to this speech. It may be self-explanatory, to the extent than anything is anymore.
I really hope you listened. Same tone he took when he cut Big Steel down to size. Like, listen. I don’t give a rat’s ass what you think or who told you differently. That’s not how it works here. I don’t take orders from the Pope. He wouldn’t take orders from the steel companies. And he called the Editors of The New York Times “sons of bitches.” During the Missile Crisis, he wouldn’t let war mongers like Gen. Curtis LeMay start World War III.
Underestimating Kennedy was a mistake that a lot of his enemies made. You know. Fancy ass rich boy from Princeton/Harvard whose Old Man brought him the Presidency. An inexperienced kid. Khruschev beat him up at a Summit in Vienna in early 1961 and it may have led to Nikita’s adventurism in Cuba with missiles. Who knows? I was young and naive, and the idea of someone telling the Catholic Church or US Steel to go to Hell was no small thing–especially as a kid who was already tiring of getting worked over by the parish priest for being a normal adolescent. Within a year or two, a lot of us would begin a staged retreat from the Catholic Church using all sorts of tactics, including going to Mass at a luncheonette, or just arriving late and leaving early (the so-called Principal Parts of the Mass). The other routine sacraments–especially, aargh, Confession–just ended. Unless you were going to Vietnam, death was typically not a major concern of a suburban white boy. If we had known anything about JFK’s sex life, dear God, I can only imagine what the result would have been: “Hey, the President does it!!!” And those were about the only mortal sins on offer for adolescent males. So, no pun intended, what the Hell? I ultimately worried more about getting caught smoking cigarettes. Even I knew the odds of roasting for all eternity because of my untimely demise at 12 were pretty small.
There was also the whole cosmopolitan thing, you know? Maybe there was a bigger world to explore than your block in West Philly. Hey, maybe I could get one of those government jobs where you were always traveling somewhere? If you had never been on an airplane, the whole buzz round Kennedy was more than a little intriguing. Berlin? London? Mexico? If you thought Broad and Snyder in South Philly was a big deal, these magnificent young men and their flying machines put ideas in your head, even if you had no idea what they were. And there were the other worldly vices of which you were dimply aware, all of which seemed to exist in abundance in Washington.
And then he was gone.
That afternoon, I walked home with another guy. I think it was probably the only time we had ever had a conversation. We must have been speculating on who benefited from Kennedy’s murder. We all knew he was dead by then. “The Russians must be dancing in the streets,” was what this fellow said to me. Actually they were not, but the Cold War had shaped our outlook. Who the Hell else would have had any conceivable reason to shoot him? Well, professional politicians knew better. The apparent snap judgment was that if this was gonna happen anywhere, Texas, with its ample supply of right-wing lunatics (yes, even then) was as good a place as any. Another Texan told me years later (I have no way of verifying this), that there was applause in some Dallas schools when the news broke. The same gentleman–a Texan mind you–told me Dallas was the only genuinely fascist city in America. I sincerely hope he was not correct about the first report, and sadly mistaken about the second. Legend has it that someone in the Presidential car–was it John Connally–observed right before the shot, “Well, you can’t say that Dallas (or maybe Texas) doesn’t love you, Mr President.” He was also reputed to have said–or it may have been his wife, Nelly, once the carnage began, “They’re out to kill us all.”
For the record, it’s been a long time since I took the Warren Commission seriously. Who did this and why–well, unfortunately, motive, means and opportunity were plentifully distributed. And that’s that.
For me. And for many of us, the real drama began that Friday evening, when Air Force One, bearing Kennedy’s body and a blood-soaked Jacqueline Kennedy, plus the accidental President, Lyndon Johnson, arrived at Andrews Air Force base. My family watched in rapt silence as the casket was extracted and Mrs Kennedy looked on. I doubt anyone alive then and now will ever forget that image, black and white or not, or the expression on her face. She was clearly in shock, but refused a change of clothes (the famous pink suit, now in the National Archives) because, it was reported, she wanted people to see what “they had done to him.” There were some who thought her actions were in poor taste. I guess her trying to recover pieces of his skull as the limo sped from the scene of the butchery in Dallas was not very ladylike either. I can imagine the descendants of these people are admirers of Sarah Palin.
The weather changed on Saturday. A cold front passed through Philly because Sunday morning seemed much colder, albeit bright and sunny. The only thing that happened to me on Saturday was I went for a ride with my Dad and cried my eyes out. He was, as usual, very understanding and told me it was ok to cry. Good old Louie. Always there for me. On Sunday, Dad and a friend of his were putting in a new thermostat to our heating system (God, I thought he could do anything; when he no longer could, I knew he wasn’t well). The tv was on–as it had been since Friday afternoon–I was half watching because the Dallas cops were supposed to transfer the supposed assassin, Lee Harvey Oswald. Well, as we all know. Oswald never made it, because he was shot on live tv by Jack Ruby. All I remember was a tumult and a lot of shouting. I did not actually see the shooting. I have no theory about the shooter, Jack Ruby, although everyone does. You want to solve riddles, be my guest.
On top of the unbelievable event, there was a scarcely slightly less implausible one. The NFL, foreshadowing its role in the necessity and centrality of violence to American life, did not cancel its schedule. Nope. They played. I really don’t remember what humbug the-then Commissioner put out about honoring the Fallen Martyr’s Memory, or some typical bullshit. Irony of ironies. The Commish was right. The Birds played to a full house at Franklin Field. Not even an atrociously bad Eagles team losing to the Redskins (get over it, that’s what they were called) on top of the assassination of President Kennedy could keep some people away from the Iggles. Amazing, right? Hey, it was and is Philly. First things first. Even I was disgusted– I, a kid who bled Green. This was all part of growing up that weekend. Business was business, national tragedy or no. Hey, the NFL played through the attack on Pearl Harbor on Sunday Dec. 7, 1941. For God’s sake, the Eagles played the Redskins in Washington that afternoon. Check me.
What follows is, admittedly, a little unclear. I don’t know if the funeral cortege I remember occurred before Kennedy was allowed to lie in state in the Rotunda of the Capitol, or as part of getting him to Arlington National Cemetery, where he was to be buried. It was, yes, a long time ago. Some of the pageantry is still sharp in my mind, especially the muffled cadence of the drums, or the riderless stallion that seemed destined to bolt with the symbolic boots reversed in the stirrup. And, for the life of me, a lot of the rest is sort of dimly veiled, much like Jackie Kennedy’s old-fashioned black veil, the sort Catholic widows wore to church. Where did John-John salute the President? A stricken and ashen-faced Jackie must have gotten the folded flag from the bier at Arlington, terrible in her beautiful grief. Somehow, I lost the thread over the weekend, almost as if time ran off its usual rails. And that doesn’t tend to happen to little kids. Now, at 72, I expect it, even in the course of a day. But then, when Catholic kids said the Prayer of the Hour in school (“Let us recall the Holy Presence of God, Let us recall His Divine Majesty”), you had your stuff together. After all, the clock determined your freedom then, so it paid to know. As in, hurry up, it’s time, as a poet said.

The following weeks the speculation and the initial hagiography began. What I recall most is the torrent of ephemera commemorating JFK, some of it in good taste, some of it not. A lot of was Sunday-supplement type stuff. Of course, you’d have to know what a Sunday newspaper was then, so I guess that doesn’t mean much. But I mean pull out photos, souvenirs of idyllic family life, records of achievement, and then the inevitable stamps, coins, God seemingly endless. Who didn’t end up with a JFK stamp First Day of Issue Cover? I was nearly obsessed with Kennedy stamps from other countries and at one time, had an ample collection, now lost to one of my adult moves here and there.
I didn’t know much about LBJ and Texas–I already knew more than I wanted by Friday night–but it seemed as if Johnson was going to get anything he wanted from Congress as a kind of debt of blood. That was fine. Especially the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which some people have cast as an “almost living memorial” to JFK. This little NPR piece (click below) is worth listening to, for a variety of reasons, not the least for its insights by John Lewis. It may not be exactly what you expected. Like Lewis said–and I agree wholeheartedly with this–when JFK died, a little bit of all of us died. Even a kid. Especially a kid. With me, it was illusions about America. It’s been a slow process, and it isn’t over yet. But that was the day it all started. So much so I thought the song “American Pie” was about JFK. I know it wasn’t but, for me, that was the day the music died, his widowed bride and all. And nothing is gonna make me change my mind. Especially now.












